Are Influencers Really the Best Marketing Strategy for a New Restaurant?
Updated: Feb 10, 2025
Published in Undrbelly Magazine
In today’s digital marketing landscape, influencers have become a powerful tool for connecting brands with audiences they might otherwise never reach. With more than 100,000 influencers on TikTok and around 65 million on Instagram, being an influencer or content creator has become a legitimate career for many, often with income that surpasses traditional office jobs.
However, amid all the "Get Ready With Me" videos and product sponsorships, where do influencers fit into food, beverage and hospitality marketing? Many restaurateurs have found success in influencer partnerships, which can provide broad audience exposure, buzz and positive word-of-mouth. Partnering with influencers can also help restaurants reach targeted niches, allowing them to market to specific follower demographics rather than casting a wide net.
But for some new restaurant owners, especially those with limited budgets, relying on influencers can be a costly and uncertain strategy. Julian Rios, co-owner of Sotto Sopra, an Italian cocktail bar that opened just two months ago in South Beach, shares this skepticism. After years of marketing his own apparel brand, Rios has a fresh perspective on the effectiveness of influencer partnerships for his new restaurant.

"I get it, influencers build a following, but does that always translate to sales for my restaurant?" Rios said over a glass of wine. "It’s hard to measure a return on the investment of giving away all this free food. We’ve been trying to get influencers in here since we opened, but sometimes it feels like a gamble. Do I really have to give $300, $400 worth of food for just one photo?"
Opening a restaurant is notoriously a major financial undertaking, often requiring months or years to see a real return on investment. This being so, so every penny spent on marketing counts. When approaching how to market a new business, there are several reasons why relying on influencers might not be the most effective investment:
Uncertain Return on Investment (ROI): One of the biggest challenges with influencer marketing is the lack of measurable ROI. Unlike traditional advertising, it’s hard to track exactly how much revenue is generated from specific influencer partnerships. Without a clear ROI, new restaurants risk wasting resources on posts and stories that may not lead to actual sales or long-term customer loyalty.
Audience Mismatch: For influencer marketing to be effective, the influencer’s audience must align with the restaurant’s target demographic. When a food-focused business partners with influencers from different niches—such as fashion or lifestyle—the likelihood of reaching genuinely interested potential diners decreases. Rios’s experience illustrates this issue: “We threw one influencer dinner, with probably 10 guests and 5 to 10 million followers between them, but most of them were in the fashion niche and I didn’t see any increase in sales after that. You have to find people that have the audience you want for your business.”
Follower Engagement Isn’t Guaranteed: High follower counts don’t necessarily translate into engagement. Many influencers have a significant portion of “ghost followers”—accounts that follow but rarely engage. For small businesses that need a high level of interaction and word-of-mouth to drive business, low engagement can make an influencer’s large following almost meaningless. It’s also not uncommon for influencers to have followers from diverse locations, many of whom aren’t local enough to visit the restaurant.
Risk of Inauthenticity: Many followers are increasingly wary of sponsored content and can detect inauthentic partnerships. When influencers promote a product, service, or restaurant without a genuine connection, audiences can view these posts as less trustworthy. For restaurants, this lack of authenticity can be particularly harmful, as word-of-mouth and reputation play critical roles in attracting diners. Relying heavily on influencers can make a restaurant seem trendy rather than dependable, which could deter customers looking for genuine culinary experiences rather than the latest hype.
Rios pointed out that, despite all the influencers he’s worked with, a single organic post from an unexpected guest drove more traffic than any planned campaign. “We had one guy come in on a Sunday brunch without us even inviting him. He posted us on his story, and I think all we comped for him was one cocktail, but by the next weekend we didn’t have a single empty table. It’s really all a gamble.”
Restaurants can use their marketing budget more effectively through alternative strategies like community engagement, local partnerships or targeted social media ads. Hosting events for locals, connecting with nearby businesses and investing in platforms like Google and Yelp, where potential diners actively look for places to eat, can often provide a more direct path to bringing people through the doors.
While influencer marketing has reshaped how brands interact with audiences, its effectiveness for new restaurants is uncertain. The high costs, risk of audience mismatch, difficulty in measuring ROI and potential for inauthenticity can make it a risky strategy for restaurants with limited budgets. As Rios’s experience shows, sometimes an authentic, organic interaction can do more for a restaurant’s reputation and sales than orchestrated influencer partnerships.
For new restaurant owners, a better approach may lie in connecting with the local community, focusing on authentic customer interactions and building a loyal base of repeat customers who can spread the word through their own positive experiences. After all, when it comes to dining, genuine recommendations often carry much more weight than a corny, ring-lit, video touting “You guys HAVE to try this!”




Comments