top of page

Old Smokey: The Legacy of Environmental Injustice

Writer: Isabelle Fitzpatrick
Isabelle Fitzpatrick
May 20, 2024
5 min read

Updated: Jan 29, 2025

Written as an assignment for JMM 544: Feature writing


“My mother. My father. My brother. My sister, and my other sister. All five died from five different kinds of cancer.” 


Hollis Gaiter, who goes by Gator, grew up minutes away from one of Miami’s most affluent neighborhoods, Coral Gables. His childhood home, which has been in his family since 1948 and he lovingly referred to as their little house on the prairie, is located across the street from George Washington Carver Middle School in the West Grove, a historically black Bahamian neighborhood founded in the late 1800s five years before the City of Miami. 


Across the corner from Gator’s house and Carver is an unassuming yellow building, once home to an active garbage incinerator. This dilapidated facade, now owned by the City of Miami and used to train future firefighters, holds the secrets to the source of mysterious and fatal health issues affecting hundreds of West Grove residents. 


Old Smokey, built by the City of Miami in 1925, used to burn thousands of pounds of garbage a day. This facility spewed ash containing chemicals like lead, arsenic, and barium into the air for almost fifty years, covering laundry lines and windows in layers of soot, until it was shut down and declared a public nuisance in 1970. These chemicals are still being found in local soil testing as recently as 2013, and are believed by local public health experts to be the cause of an apparent cancer cluster that’s been recognized in the West Grove’s population.


“It was… it was really bad, ‘cause the smoke would come down, and to us, it was like snow. We used to play in it,” said Gator. “We’d even sneak inside and go play in there, but we didn’t know how dangerous it would become.” 


As the years have passed, West Grove residents, like Gator and his family, have realized that this plant has had a long-lasting impact on not just their childhood memories, but their health. 


“A lot of them died off, and a lot of them are still dying,” said Gator when asked if others in the West Grove have been affected similarly to his family. “There was a week when we lost seven of our elderly at once to cancer. Seven. In one week. And a lot of people moved out of this area, but they took those ailments with them.”


Across the country, minority and low-income communities like the West Grove have had similar experiences with respective garbage incinerators and industrial facilities, as these communities are often targeted for the construction of undesirable industrial activity due to cheaper land prices and the fact that their residents often don’t have the political sway to fight the decision. And just like the Grove, these communities have also recently experienced cancer clusters in their populations. 


Teresa Pinto, an environmental lawyer who teaches environmental policy at the University of Miami, has seen a multitude of cases just like Old Smokey through her work with UM Law’s Environmental Justice Clinic. 


“There's a case that I worked on in the city of Fort Myers in Dunbar, a historically black neighborhood, and the city was basically maintaining an open dump in what they called a park, in the middle of the neighborhood,” recounted Pinto. “So children were playing in this waste, because they covered it with grass and called it a park, and now 30 years later most of those families are seeing cancers, respiratory illnesses, asthma, and kidney disease at rates higher than populations within similar demographics.” 


In her line of work, Pinto often advocates for victims of circumstances like this in environmental justice lawsuits. Environmental justice is an offshoot of the Civil Rights movement tracing its roots back to the 1980s, with the primary goal of ensuring a clean environment and standard of living for all citizens, regardless of race or socioeconomic status. 


“It was a response to this idea that our systems in the United States are very much working on a racial hierarchy, and that because of that our environmental degradation and our toxic pollutants are ending up primarily in black and low-income communities,” said Pintot. “The goal is simple: a healthy planet. We have to bridge the gap between humanity and the planet, and we don’t get there until everybody gets equal treatment.”


Residents of the West Grove, including Gator’s family and his neighbors, have been pursuing a similar environmental justice lawsuit against the City of Miami since 2019. Gator has assumed the role of community leader in this suit, meaning he often speaks on behalf of his neighbors in court.


“At this point we’ve made it to the second phase. The city has finally acknowledged and paid out the broader civil lawsuit,” said Gator. “But now, we’re at the part where we’re pursuing individual medical reparations for our people, and the city really doesn’t want to pay up.”


Members of Gator’s ex-wife’s family went through a similar lawsuit in Fort Lauderdale, pertaining to a garbage dump located in the historically black Durrs neighborhood. They won their case, and the city paid out an $18 million settlement in 2020. 


“We’re working to get what we deserve but nobody really cares, due to us being a predominantly black community,” said Gator. “If it happened anywhere else? Like over there in Coral Gables? They’d be all over it. That’s actually what made them shut it down.”


Old Smokey’s status was declared as a public nuisance in 1970, coincidentally only a few years after Miami desegregated its public schools in the late 1960s and rezoned. This meant the white children of Coral Gables would have to attend George Washington Carver, exposing them to the pollution of Old Smokey.


“If they shut it down, that means that they knew it was a problem,” said Gator. “So if it was a problem for them, it was a problem for us, but they never wanted to acknowledge it when we said it. They tried to cover it up at that school with artificial turf, to make us think they were doing something for the neighborhood, but they’re only hurting it because you can not cover a lie.”


Although Gator and other residents of the West Grove continue to face the devastating consequences of a decision they did not make for their community, they are optimistic that the media coverage of Old Smokey’s case has raised public awareness of a very wide-spread issue.


“We still have hope,” said Gator. “If people talk about it, and enough people start to speak up about it, we can really get a lot done. Not just here, but in other black neighborhoods across America too.”

 

 

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

© 2023 by Isabelle Fitzpatrick. All rights reserved.

bottom of page