top of page

A New Phenomenon: Tip-flation

Writer: Isabelle Fitzpatrick
Isabelle Fitzpatrick
Mar 10, 2024
4 min read

Updated: Jan 29, 2025

Written as an assignment for JMM 544: Feature writing


As she visited Miami for spring break, Hannah Rubin was excited to try an authentic empanada for the first time. After finding a local cafe and choosing which flavor looked best, Rubin paid and was then asked by the cashier, “And if you wouldn’t mind just answering a few questions on that screen for me please?”

 

This question was accompanied by the turning around of a small tablet, with a suggested 18%, 20%, or 22% tip, with “No tip” or “Custom tip” hidden in tiny letters at the very bottom of the screen. Rubin panicked, thought for a second, and looked around to make sure nobody could see her press “No tip.” 

 

This dreaded interaction is becoming more prevalent across America, with consumers being prompted to tip for products and services they have never traditionally tipped for in the past. This phenomenon, of more tip prompts and climbing automatic gratuities being added to checks at restaurants, is called tipflation. And Americans are getting sick of it. 

 

“In what world does it make sense that we’re tipping people to make Subway sandwiches? I told you how to make it, I should be getting tipped!” said TikTok user Olivia Scobie from upstate New York, whose comments were flooded with people across the country agreeing and sharing their out of control tipping stories. 

 

Experts have named this feeling “tip fatigue,” where consumers tip less overall because they’re overwhelmed by how often they’re being asked to do so and don’t know where (or if they even can) draw the line. 

 

Historically, tipping only really occurred in a few specific transactions: sit down restaurants, personal grooming appointments, food delivery, and taking a cab. While tipping of course can’t be forced upon customers, restaurants often pay their servers and bartenders a lower wage with the expectation that the customer will provide ample compensation.

 

In fact, the federal minimum wage for tipped, sit-down service employees is only $2.13 an hour, so some employees do rely on tips for the majority of their income. 

 

“I get that people might not want to tip in a coffee shop or a fast-food place, but if they’re coming to eat at a sit-down place, they should expect to have to leave a tip,” said Taylor Deas, a server at the Loews Coral Gables Hotel’s lobby restaurant. “We make less than minimum wage and we don’t even get to keep the whole tip either; I have to give 5% of my tips each night to the bartenders making my tables’ drinks, 8% to the food runner, and 10% to the busser. It’s a team effort.”

 

This tip sharing practice is generally standard across the restaurant industry and these employees’ wages are federally mandated accordingly, meaning the decision not to tip affects more than just one employee.

 

Some restaurants even practice a tip pool, meaning all servers share all their tips equally for the night, meaning a decision not to tip affects the entire staff. 

 

Deas also said she decided to apply to her current job mostly because they include an 18% automatic gratuity on their checks.

 

“I understand the automatic gratuity annoys some people, but you can’t trust people to tip how they should, especially in a big city like Miami. I would never work in a place without an auto-grat. If I take care of a table for three hours and they stiff me, I’m basically working for free. That’s not fair at all,” Deas stated.

 

However, since the expansion of easy-to-use Point of Sale technologies like Square and Toast, and the push to appreciate service employees more during the COVID-19 pandemic, tipping is now appearing in more transactions than ever: coffee shops, fast food, car washes, retail, completely digital purchases, and even self-checkout kiosks. And oftentimes, these employees are already being paid minimum wage, if not more. This includes Subway employees, who make at least $12 an hour before tips in the state of Florida. 

 

So why are people tipping these employees? One reason is that the use of a screen where a customer is required to answer whether they want to tip or not, rather than the traditional tip jar, has been found to increase tipping.

 

In a survey by PYMNTS about how much consumers would tip in each situation, the median tips if prompted by a screen were 15% of the purchase’s subtotal, when a tip jar resulted in just 10%. 

 

These screens also create another big factor in whether or not a customer tips: social pressure. In the same survey, the social pressure of the screen broadcasting their choice to tip increases tip totals by 50%. Whether it be the employee, a stranger, or family/friends, people tip more when they think someone will see their decision. 

 

But these same customers who are tipping in more industries than ever also resent the practice as a whole. In a 2023 survey by Pew Research Center, 40% of American participants opposed suggested tips, and only 24% favored them. The same survey found that 72% of participants oppose automatic gratuities or service charges being tacked onto their bills, and only 10% favored them. But the decision to tip heavily lies in the quality of service; 77% of adults surveyed said that is their main decider. 

 

“I just think it’s a little ridiculous,” said Lilyan Bonitz, a junior at the University of Miami. “I’ll obviously tip at a restaurant or an Uber driver, I think that’s normal. But the other day I ordered a lemonade at the farmer’s market, which they poured from a pitcher into my cup in 10 seconds, and the screen asked me if I wanted to leave a 20, 22, or 24% tip. I just don’t get it.”

 

Lilyan’s sentiment is echoed by a large portion of Americans, of which only 34% said they find it easy to know when/how much they should be tipping (Pew). The large majority has no idea. The overwhelmingness of constant tip prompts and raising percentages is a key factor in the aforementioned sensation of tip fatigue. And it’s real.

 

“Companies have already been raising prices, but now they’re asking me to pay their employees for doing their jobs? That the company supposedly pays them for? It makes it hard to tell where I even should be tipping anymore, it’s just confusing,” said Bonitz. “It makes me not want to tip anyone, but I do anyways, cause I feel bad.”

 

 

 
 
 

Comments


© 2023 by Isabelle Fitzpatrick. All rights reserved.

bottom of page